Hey there,
Actually, the roster we are using is neither.
Its a custom PHP script I developed mainly for our raid system - we use a custom one so I couldn't use anything off the shelf. The other components, the roster, artisan listing, top 10 stats, etc, were created to support it. The roster used to sync itself from the eq2players site, but I havn't gotten around to fixing it since they updated the eq2players site.
Because it is just a clean PHP script that outputs it, I wrap it into a Joomla page, so no component is required.